SOAP vs REST: What are the differences between the two API protocols and which one is better?

APIs are the backbone of modern software development, but how do you decide whether to build with REST or SOAP? The answer lies in understanding their core differences and how these align with your project needs.

Two of the most common protocols for building APIs are REST (Representational State Transfer) and SOAP (Simple Object Access Protocol). While both aim to achieve the same general objective, their fundamental differences make each more suitable for specific types of projects. In this article, we will delve into their characteristics, advantages and disadvantages, providing a detailed comparison to help you make the best decision.

What is REST?

REST (Representational State Transfer) is an architectural style for designing web services based on principles such as resource utilisation and the use of HTTP verbs (GET, POST, PUT, DELETE). It is characterised by its simplicity and flexibility, making it the most popular choice for modern API development.

Advantages of REST

Let's take a closer look at what makes REST a popular choice for developers, here are the main benefits of REST: 

1. Simplicity: REST uses JSON or XML for data exchange, with JSON being lightweight and more readable.
2. Scalability: Designed to handle a high volume of transactions effectively.
3. Compatibility with HTTP: Builds on existing web standards such as URIs and HTTP status codes.
4. Platform independence: Works with a wide variety of programming languages and operating systems.
5. Ease of use: More intuitive for developers due to its resource-based structure.

Disadvantages of REST

While REST has become the go-to choice for many developers, it is not without its limitations. Understanding these drawbacks is crucial to evaluating whether REST is the right fit for your project. Here are some of the challenges and considerations to keep in mind if you decide to use REST:

1. Limited security features: While HTTPS can be implemented, it does not have a built-in security protocol like SOAP.
2. Lack of support for complex transactions: May be less suitable for enterprise systems requiring robust transactional operations.

What is SOAP?

SOAP (Simple Object Access Protocol) is a protocol based on XML for exchanging information in computer networks. It is often used in enterprise environments where security and reliability are of paramount importance.

Advantages of SOAP

Here are the key benefits that make SOAP a reliable option in many contexts:

1. Security: Includes WS-Security, offering an advanced level of protection for communications.
2. Reliability: Supports ACID (Atomicity, Consistency, Isolation, Durability) transactions.
3. Standardisation: Strictly defined by standards ensuring compatibility across different systems.
4. Support for complex messaging: Capable of handling complex data structures and large volumes of information.
5. Enterprise integration: Ideal for legacy systems and enterprise applications requiring high levels of control.

Disadvantages of SOAP

Despite its strengths, SOAP is not without its challenges. Below are some of the disadvantages that come with using SOAP:

1. Complexity: Implementation and configuration tend to be more challenging.
2. Lower performance: The use of XML introduces more overhead compared to JSON.
3. Rigidity: Strict standards can limit flexibility in certain cases.

REST vs SOAP: What's the Difference? Key Comparison

Which is better, REST or SOAP? This section provides a detailed comparison between REST and SOAP, highlighting their differences in key areas to help you determine which protocol aligns best with your needs. 

What are the similarities between SOAP and REST?

While SOAP and REST have significant differences, they also share some similarities:

1. API communication: Both are used to enable communication between different systems via APIs, allowing applications to exchange data and perform operations.
2. Platform independence: Both are platform-independent, meaning they can be used with various programming languages and operating systems.
3. Internet protocol use: Both typically rely on common internet protocols such as HTTP and HTTPS for message transport.
4. Support for XML: Both support XML as a data format, though REST often prefers JSON for its simplicity and performance.
5. Scalability: Both are capable of supporting scalable systems, depending on how they are implemented and configured.

These shared traits highlight their common purpose in facilitating system interoperability, despite their different approaches and use cases.

Which should I choose, REST or SOAP? Detailed comparison of use cases

Here’s a detailed breakdown:

Choose REST if

• Your application requires simplicity and speed: REST’s lightweight nature and use of JSON make it faster to implement and more efficient for web and mobile applications where performance is critical.
• You are building a Public API: When building a public API, REST is often the preferred choice, thanks to its straightforward design and widespread acceptance within the developer community.
• Your project involves Microservices: REST is well-suited for communication between microservices due to its stateless nature and ease of integration.
• You prioritise flexibility over strict standards: REST allows for more flexibility in design, making it a better choice for projects with evolving requirements.

Choose SOAP if

• Security and reliability are critical: SOAP’s WS-Security protocol provides advanced security features, making it ideal for applications handling sensitive data such as in healthcare or finance.
• You need to handle complex transactions: SOAP supports ACID transactions, ensuring data consistency and reliability in complex operations.
• Your application integrates legacy systems: SOAP’s standardisation and support for XML make it a better choice for enterprise environments with legacy systems.
• You require strong standards compliance: SOAP’s strict adherence to standards ensures compatibility and reliability across different platforms and systems.

When making your choice, consider the following questions:

• What is the primary purpose of your API? Is it to serve modern web or mobile applications, or to integrate complex enterprise systems?
• Does your project require high security and transaction reliability?
• How important is performance and simplicity compared to standardisation and compatibility?
• What level of expertise does your team have with REST or SOAP?

By carefully evaluating your project’s needs, you can select the protocol that not only meets your technical requirements but also aligns with your broader business goals.

SOAP vs REST: Who will win and dominate the API Landscape?

The debate between SOAP and REST has been ongoing for years, each vying to prove its superiority in specific contexts. But is there a definitive winner? The answer depends on how you measure success. The following factors can help clarify this:

1. Adoption and ecosystem: REST has become the dominant choice for modern API development due to its simplicity, speed and compatibility with web technologies. As a result, REST is often seen as the winner for most modern web and mobile applications.
2. Enterprise-level applications: In environments where security, transactional integrity and strict standards are crucial, SOAP continues to hold a strong position. For industries like banking, healthcare and government, SOAP often emerges as the winner.
3. Future-proofing: REST’s adaptability to new data formats and evolving technologies gives it an edge in terms of future relevance. However, SOAP’s adherence to standards ensures its reliability for long-term enterprise use.
4. Trends and developer preference: REST’s simplicity and ease of learning have made it the preferred choice for developers, further contributing to its widespread adoption. SOAP, while more complex, remains indispensable for certain high-stakes scenarios.

Ultimately, the "winner" depends on the specific requirements of your project. Both REST and SOAP have proven their value and reliability and the decision should be based on careful analysis of your technical and business needs.

Conclusion

In essence, REST and SOAP are tools in the developer’s toolbox, each excelling in different scenarios. By carefully analysing your project’s needs (performance, security, complexity, or scalability) you can confidently select the protocol that will drive your application’s success. Remember, the right choice isn't about the popularity of the protocol but its suitability for your specific context.

If you’re still uncertain about which protocol is best for your project, don’t hesitate to contact us. Our team of experts can guide you through the decision-making process.

Talk to our experts!

Contact our team and discover the cutting-edge technologies that will empower your business.

Get in touch

Mariluz Usero

Share